hmmmmm....

[Weasel]

EDIT: Due to stink's persuasive post, I have changed my list to a top 10.

dj
Weasel
w00t
t34
supra
stinkfingers
kj
getsome
Cloud
Bolo

[supratank]

ill take a shot at this. :-)

this is a scrum talent list - best players list - in order from best to most challenged.

ill also guess that its created by w00t? i base this on the placement of 3 players which i will not name. i may be wrong here.

am i close?

[fishtank]

^No, that can't be right. Perhaps it's a list of the currently active players.

[TumbleWeed]

If that's his top players list ..... I suppose he's in titled to his opinion.

[Weasel]

You guys can post your lists on here as well. I'd be interested to see your opinions.

Supra is right, although w00t did not make. From supra's speculation, i have changed the rankings of a few players. I'll also expect an explanation later from you, supra.

Fish, you havent played in pickup games recently and you're a bit rusty so i'm not sure where to put you. This explains why you are not on the list. In a sense, you are right.

Tumbleweed, i think ill move you up a few spots.

[parCAT]

Well, after some thought, I've rearranged your list to reflect my top 32 players. There were a few I didn't even put on mine, reasons are because they just don't play enough. My list is not meant to offend or degrade anyone. These are skill levels that PARCAT sees, and others may see them differently. If you're not on this list, you either don't play when I do or you don't play enough.

dj
weasel
t-34
cloud
w00t
getsome
kj
supra
jay
stink
magenta
zante
bolo
jangles
parcat
rooks
delta
belikin
blind cide
smacky
delta
rx
majorpain
gray
jedi
tumbleweed
baba
speedo
grrreat
c_lion
the axe
falcon
maxwell
will
kemek

[Speedo]

Speedo is too low on either list . Maybe it's my high ping. Just wait until I move back to a place with better connection.

However, that being said, I believe there is a highest level all TS players achieve. With eight of these players in a game, a TS match will always come down to luck (spawns, etc.), which players is paying the most attention, or who has the best connection. All of the "good" players know TS strategy, which isn't too complicated when you think about it. For instance, take a guy like Weasel, that Par has at the top of her list, and a newer player like Tumbleweed. I bet if Weasel could only score 13 times out of 20 on Magenta, Tumbleweed might only score 12. Not a big difference. Swapping players like these won't really advantage or hinder a team.

MHO, from a never-played-PSL guy

[Weasel]

well speedo i like how you play but you haven't played recently and you are rusty. you wouldve been higher but....

[Cloud]

[stinkfingers]

A return to the top scrummers lists...take...er? Like 15, 20?

Has there ever been a more simultaneously silly and retarded thing than to make a top scrummers list and place yourself firmly at the top of it?

gay!

And i mean that in the derogatory sense, not the honorable one. i would offer as a reflection on some of the picks here that some of you make the obvious blunder of mistaking shooting for playing scrum. A great shooter is not always someone who understands the game well.

For those of you who've made this basic and noob mistake, add ten positions to your self rankings: you don't really understand the game.

fags! I mean that in the 8th grade sense.

BTW: there was a time when a top scrummers list meant something. At a time of dwindling participation, this is something akin to
THE TALLEST DWARF CONTEST.

eat it.